Gaiam Dry-Grip vs YogaAccessories Deluxe: Which One Should You Buy?
Both are PVC yoga mats, but the Dry-Grip costs about $48 more for a coated surface and firmer tested support. The Deluxe gives you more thickness, four extra inches of length, and a much lower list price. We would pay the premium only if the Gaiam’s support and surface suit your practice; its hot-yoga pitch needs a closer look.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases made through links on this page. How this works
The quick answer
GearLab rated the Dry-Grip higher for comfort and support, 8 out of 10 versus the Deluxe’s 6.5. Dry traction also favored the Gaiam, but wet scores were weak for both. The Deluxe is longer at 72 inches, thicker at 6.2 mm, and about $48 cheaper at list price.
For regular unheated yoga where you want firmer support, we would choose the Dry-Grip if 68 inches fits. For occasional classes, slow stretching, or a low-cost first mat, get the Deluxe. We would shop beyond both if sweaty hand grip is the main problem.
Get the Dry-Grip if...
- You want the firmer support GearLab reported
- You prefer a smooth coated yoga surface
- You value its higher dry-grip test score
- You want Gaiam’s advertised lifetime guarantee
Get the Deluxe if...
- You would rather save about $48 at list price
- You want four more inches of length
- You prefer softer foam for slow floor poses
- You want the lower brand-listed weight at 3.6 pounds
Side by side
Price
The YogaAccessories lists for about $48 less.
$69.98
List price · check price at Amazon
$21.99
List price · check price at Amazon
Thickness
The YogaAccessories is 24% thicker.
5 mm0.2″
6.2 mm0.24″
Weight
The YogaAccessories is 0.6 lbs lighter.
4.25 lbs1.9 kg
3.6 lbs1.63 kg
Size
The YogaAccessories is 4″ longer; same width.
Same on both
- PVC construction
- 24 inches wide
- Explicitly described as latex-free
- Limited wet traction in GearLab testing
Full specs
Dimensions
Materials & build
Buying
Both use PVC, but the surfaces differ
The Dry-Grip is Gaiam’s coated 5 mm yoga mat. The YogaAccessories Deluxe is thicker, textured PVC foam sold as an inexpensive studio mat. We would put both on a shortlist for ordinary yoga, then ask whether the Gaiam’s smoother surface and firmer tested support justify about $48 more.
The cheaper Deluxe already gives you more length and more nominal padding. Paying more only makes sense if you want what changes under your hands and feet. We lean toward the Deluxe for occasional stretching and a low-cost first mat. The Dry-Grip earns a look for regular unheated practice where you prefer support with less sinking into foam.
Both brands explicitly describe these mats as latex-free. If natural rubber is off your shopping list, you do not have to pay more for the Gaiam to avoid it. The shared PVC material also means the upgrade needs to earn its price through construction and performance, rather than a change to rubber.
The Gaiam tests firmer despite being thinner
The Deluxe measures 6.2 mm thick and the Dry-Grip 5 mm. GearLab gave the Dry-Grip 8 out of 10 for comfort and support, against 6.5 for the YogaAccessories. Those results are a better guide to this decision than assuming the thicker mat must be more supportive.
In the same published comparison, testers described the Dry-Grip as firm and secure on the floor. They noted a lingering handprint when pressing into the Deluxe’s softer foam. We favor the Gaiam for standing sequences and balances, while the Deluxe remains a sensible choice if you specifically like a softer surface for slow stretches.
Dry-Grip wins dry traction, not wet traction
GearLab’s dry-grip scores were 6.5 out of 10 for the Gaiam and 5.5 for the Deluxe. Wet scores were 3.5 and 4 respectively. That is a modest dry advantage for the more expensive mat, followed by a weak wet result for both. The Gaiam name should not be read as a promise of secure hands under every condition.
We would not buy either mainly for hot yoga. Gaiam markets its moisture-wicking topcoat for heated practice, but that pitch is stronger than its independent wet-grip result. For frequent sweaty classes, see our Dry-Grip vs IUGA comparison before treating these two as your only options.
The Deluxe is longer for much less money
Both are 24 inches wide. The Deluxe is 72 inches long, compared with 68 for the standard Dry-Grip. If you are close to the length of a 68-inch mat, those four extra inches can be a useful improvement without changing brands or paying a premium.
Gaiam also offers the Dry-Grip Long & Wide at 78 by 26 inches. We would consider that separate size if you like the coated surface but need room. The standard model here is shorter than the Deluxe, so decide whether it fits before weighing smaller differences in grip or warranty.
The thinner mat is not the lighter one
Gaiam lists the Dry-Grip at 4.25 pounds; YogaAccessories lists the Deluxe at 3.6. We use those brand-listed figures in the table. GearLab measured its Dry-Grip sample heavier still, so a frequent walker should not treat the Gaiam’s slimmer sheet as evidence of an easier carry.
On the other hand, thickness affects the size of the roll. Check your carrier if it fits a conventional yoga mat tightly. We would not make a short drive to class hinge on either weight, but a long walk can change the recommendation. The Deluxe saves money and listed weight; the Gaiam offers the thinner format.
Allow time to air out the Gaiam
Gaiam advises airing the Dry-Grip for two to three days after unwrapping, then spot cleaning with a damp cloth and mild detergent. Its instructions say to dry flat and avoid extended sunlight. If the mat is for a class tomorrow, the initial airing period is worth knowing before you order.
GearLab also observed dye transfer from the Dry-Grip and recommended buffing the surface with a towel before first use. We would follow that advice before practicing in pale clothing. This is a specific downside of a mat we otherwise prefer for support. Paying more for the coated surface does not eliminate practical annoyances.
A lifetime guarantee versus unused-item returns
Gaiam advertises a lifetime guarantee on the Dry-Grip product page. The page does not fully define every wear exclusion, so ask about a particular claim before assuming a worn surface is covered. GearLab’s comparison also flags the Dry-Grip’s durability as a weakness. We would not buy it expecting the guarantee to settle every problem.
YogaAccessories’ return policy requires unused, resalable items and contact within 30 days of purchase. The buyer pays return shipping. That is a materially narrower published promise, but it does not establish how long a particular Deluxe will last. A store return window and a product warranty answer different questions.
The extra $48 buys support you need to want
The Dry-Grip lists for $69.98 and the Deluxe for $21.99. Check the Gaiam price at Amazon and the Deluxe price at Amazon. These are retailer price checks; the amounts compared here come from the brand product pages.
For a class once in a while, we would save the difference. For a regular practice where soft foam moving beneath a foot already bothers you, the Gaiam’s test results give a concrete reason to pay more. We would not spend the premium merely because the packaging mentions hot yoga or because a guarantee sounds like proof of longer life.
Bottom line
Get the Dry-Grip if you want a smoother yoga surface with firmer support backed by independent testing, and its 68-inch length fits. Its drawbacks are the higher price, weak wet traction, and reported dye transfer.
Get the Deluxe for a low-cost starter mat, extra length, and soft cushioning during unheated practice. Expect the foam to compress rather than behave like a dense studio mat. If slippery hands in a hot class are the problem, we would expand the shortlist before buying either.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Is Gaiam Dry-Grip worth about $48 more than the Deluxe?
- For regular unheated practice, the Dry-Grip’s firmer tested support and higher dry-grip score can justify the extra cost. GearLab rated comfort and support 8 out of 10 for Gaiam and 6.5 for YogaAccessories. We would save the money for occasional stretching or a low-cost first mat.
- Which has better grip when wet?
- GearLab scored the Dry-Grip 3.5 out of 10 wet and the YogaAccessories 4. Both are weak results. Dry scores were 6.5 for Gaiam and 5.5 for YogaAccessories. We would not choose either specifically for reliable traction during heavy sweating.
- Which mat gives taller people more room?
- The Deluxe is 72 inches long, compared with 68 inches for the standard Dry-Grip. Both are 24 inches wide. Gaiam also sells a separate 78 by 26 inch Dry-Grip Long & Wide if you want its surface in a larger size.
- Does extra thickness make the Deluxe more supportive?
- Not necessarily. The Deluxe is 6.2 mm thick versus 5 mm for the Dry-Grip, but GearLab rated the thinner Gaiam higher for comfort and support. Testers described the Dry-Grip as firm and observed a lingering handprint in the Deluxe’s softer foam.
- Can the Gaiam Dry-Grip transfer color to clothes?
- GearLab reported surface dye rubbing off the Dry-Grip and recommended buffing it with a towel before first use to help prevent clothing stains. Gaiam also advises airing a new mat for two to three days, spot cleaning, and drying flat.
- What guarantees do the Dry-Grip and Deluxe have?
- Gaiam advertises a lifetime guarantee, without fully describing every wear exclusion on the product page. YogaAccessories publishes 30-day direct-store returns for unused, resalable items, with return shipping paid by the buyer. The Deluxe return window is not a used-mat trial or proof of a particular lifespan.
Related comparisons
- YogaAccessories Extra Thick Deluxe 1/4" vs Gaiam Essentials 6mm
- Manduka X vs Gaiam Performance Dry-Grip 5mm
- Gaiam Premium 6mm vs YogaAccessories Extra Thick Deluxe 1/4"
- YogaAccessories Extra Thick Deluxe 1/4" vs Gruper TPE 6mm
- JadeYoga Level One vs Gaiam Performance Dry-Grip 5mm
- Gaiam Performance Dry-Grip 5mm vs IUGA Eco Friendly Non Slip PU
- Amazon Basics 1/4 Inch Thick TPE vs YogaAccessories Extra Thick Deluxe 1/4"
- Manduka Begin vs Gaiam Performance Dry-Grip 5mm
- Gaiam Premium Reversible 6mm vs YogaAccessories Extra Thick Deluxe 1/4"



